©Helen Pugh Photography
www.helenpughphotography.com
tel: 07837533051
Scottish Portrait Awards 2024 entry
A Scottish full-service law firm Gilson Gray has successfully concluded a landmark two-year international football employment dispute on behalf of former Accra Hearts of Oak Sporting Club technical director Rene Hiddink.
Led by David Winnie, partner and head of sport at the firm, the case is believed to be the first successful claim by a technical director for termination without just cause before FIFA’s Football Tribunal, marking a significant development in FIFA’s employment dispute framework.
Hiddink’s three-year contract with the Ghanaian club was terminated without lawful justification in June 2024. Gilson Gray subsequently brought proceedings before FIFA, which confirmed its jurisdiction and, in June 2025, upheld Hiddink’s claim, ordering the club to pay USD $146,400 in compensation plus five per cent interest.
When the club failed to comply, Gilson Gray pursued enforcement through FIFA’s regulatory framework, resulting in sporting sanctions including restrictions on player registrations. Enforcement proceedings were also brought before the High Court in Accra under the New York Convention and Ghana’s Alternative Dispute Resolution Act 2010.
Despite the court dismissing the enforcement application, the FIFA award remained final and binding and the sporting sanctions continued. Following sustained enforcement efforts, Accra Hearts of Oak ultimately paid the compensation and accrued interest on 6 August 2026, bringing the two-year dispute to a successful conclusion.
The case highlights the expanding application of FIFA’s dispute resolution framework to senior football personnel, as well as the challenges of enforcing international sporting awards across jurisdictions.
David Winnie said: “This was a complex and hard-fought dispute that raised important jurisdictional and enforcement issues within international football. The case establishes an important precedent for technical directors and other senior football professionals seeking to rely on FIFA’s dispute resolution framework.
While the challenges encountered during enforcement were considerable, the ultimate outcome demonstrates that persistence, coupled with FIFA’s regulatory powers, can secure compliance even where a club is initially unwilling to honour a binding award.”
